Politics Issues
Defense
Education
Environment
Freedom
Health Care
Politics & Democracy
Social SecurityPI Parody Ad
| Why Public Demonstration Is a Useless Form of Activism |
| Written by M. Harrison | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Tuesday, 01 January 2008 08:46 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
One, Two, Three, Four, Please Don't Protest Anymore Since the 1970s and up until recently, there had been a relative decline in mass protesting as a popular method of political activism, at least in America. Many took this decline to indicate the public's enlightenment as to the modern pointlessness of the public demonstration. But alas, it was not so, and the world now finds itself in a sort of protesting renaissance. The ultimately unsuccessful protests against the Iraq War (an empirical example of their political impotence) were hailed by many a burnt-out hippie nostalgist as the reincarnation of the Vietnam protests. Now protests are fully coming back in fashion, with even the Lebanese recently offering their own demonstrations, unintentionally satirizing their own state of affairs. (The Lebanese president, Fouad Siniora, remarked that the displays of pointless outrage made him "proud of our democracy." How valuable is a democracy with public protests but without a government capable of even controlling its own territory, you ask? Answer: Not very.)
Even conservatives have joined the nascent ochlocratic movement, organizing their own counter-protests to the anti-war protests. Their protests, however, ultimately tended to underline the foolishness of their decision, as the conservatives wound up grossly outnumbered by the parading pacifists. But nevertheless, protesting by various groups for various subjects of political interest, recently immigration in the United States, continues apace. Protests and demonstrations may have been legitimate in the past for groups with otherwise few legal rights (e.g. the Civil Rights Movement), or those facing severe threats to personal liberty (e.g. Vietnam draft protests). But the protest as a form of political activism has now become worthless in twenty-first century political society. The conditions for the necessity of protesting no longer exist, and with myriad alternatives for political expression, the protests end up being nothing but irksome political distractions. 1. They have no logical argument Presumably, the well-meaning protestor expects a positive, persuaded reaction to his demonstration. If he is demonstrating for the sake of demonstrating, that may be his choice, but we can safely assume he expects his activity to serve a purpose, that is, to affect public opinion. What does such persuasion look like? "Gee, I was really on the fence about this issue," says the hypothetical persuaded passer-by. "But now that I've seen all of these people I've never met on my local street, holding signs, wearing T-shirts emblazoned with bald partisan assertions, and generally shouting loudly various angry refrains about the alleged motives of our elected leaders, I am definitely convinced that the legislature should attempt to pursue alternative action, per the requests of these fine protesters." Of course, it never works that way, simply because a) political persuasion is not facilitated by a 50 mph drive-by of community activists, and, more importantly, b) the protest makes no attempt whatsoever at forming a reasoned, principled political argument. Political reform shouldn't arise from a demand that one group of citizens see a contentious issue the same way as another group of citizens, simply because one group of citizens has signs, banners, and pithy chants in the form of rhyming couplets. Reform should arise from lively debate and the positive contentions about why a policy is wrong or right for the nation. Protesting, as a method of ipse dixit assertion, automatically precludes the possibility of doing so. Volume should never persuade, and outrage should never fuel public policy. 2. Protesting creates a suffocating environment of extremism and irrationality Even those protesters who disprove the stereotype of the angry activist, shouting axioms of political philosophy and public policy recommendations instead of vile obscenities, are still victims of the protesting environment in which they find themselves. Calm, reasonable voices will always be drowned out in a sea of impatient, angry voices, and protesting serves as no exception. In fact, the very point of protesting is to loudly call attention to collectivist outrage. More than this, many protests suffer from a structural disadvantage: the fact that they are often planned, promoted and bankrolled by extremist organizations. This has no logical effect on the protest itself, and is certainly not the fault of the more moderate participants, but serves to cement the public perception that the protesters are nothing but crackpot activists, shattering the political effectiveness of the demonstration. This perception has a strong effect on the policy markers who are, after all, supposedly the very target of the protests. While these officials are likely to already harbor negligible concern for the whims of public opinion, the medium of hysterical protests translates this flippancy into utter contempt, steeling the resolve of politicians against the very position the protesters hope to forward. Tony Blair, for example, responded to the recent Lebanese protests by saying, "I've got used to demonstrations in my own country and demonstrations elsewhere, as well." By "used to," of course, he means "used to completely ignoring." Anyone want to hazard a guess about how much George W. Bush cares about your protest? 3. Strength in numbers is not true strength Hysteria and extremism notwithstanding, the protest doctrine also forwards another troubling feature - that large numbers of people equate to ideological correctness. Protest organizers often gloat about their high turnouts, supposing without justification that said turnout somehow enhances their political viewpoint itself. Unfortunately, the popular viewpoint is often an incorrect one. One can view the Billboard pop charts for musical confirmation of this principle. In politics, the principle has shown public opinion to be quite reactionary. Many new, innovative and ultimately beneficial policies were at one point rabidly resisted by masses averse to change. The French now serve as Exhibit A of such aversion, but the Americans are far from immune to its effects. One among many examples of reactionary American public opinion was the widespread public opposition to the legalization of interracial marriage, as well as desegregation itself. It is wise to recall Eleanor Roosevelt's apothegm that what is popular is not always right, and what is right is not always popular. Unfortunately for the protesters, the Constitution agrees: it doesn't require legislation to be approved by the street mob. 4. There are many enlightened methods of activism available in lieu of demonstration Outrage is not exclusively expressed through mass protest. Methods of expressing political displeasure without sacrificing reason and rationality involve speaking through the civilized media of the 21st century. Methods for doing this include the use of televised debate, advertisement, newspaper column writing and/or letter writing, internet blogging and publication, magazine publication, legal challenges, organized boycott, and many more. There is no excuse for protesting as the only option for activism. Put down the "Bush is a War Criminal" sign, activists, and pick up a pencil and paper. 5. Any success of the protest could be achieved otherwise; the protest itself is superfluous The only conceivable benefit of public demonstration, although a commonly-mentioned one, is that protests can raise public awareness of issues. This is almost always a positive development, obviously, and thus is cited by protesters as one of the civic advantages of a protest-happy citizenry. (Giving MoveOn.org activists something to do on the weekends is the other advantage, one supposes.) But public awareness, while desirable, does not require a public protest, nor is public protest even the best way to achieve public awareness. Protesting bundles the benefit of awareness, which could be quite easily achieved through a variety of other aforementioned media, with a slew of counterproductive techniques that delegitimize the cause itself and inhibit the function of enlightened democracy.
The above work is the opinion of the author, and not necessarily that of the Prometheus Institute.
Bookmark
Email This
Trackback(0)
Comments (43)
Enrico Purita
said:
|
TrackBack URI for this entry
Subscribe to this comment's feed |
... Your article has its merits, but it is a very one-sided view of the issue. Protest, yes, is dominated by blind extremism that is based both in idealism and impracticality. However, you are forgetting protest when it is executed properly. Civil Disobedience and breaking laws that one feels is unjust is certainly a form of protest. Protest is the uniform action of many to combat something that an individual cannot combat on his/her own. Protesting is not always just walking on a picket line shouting at passerbys. Though this has its merits on a smaller scale. In colleges or the workplace, sometimes a large group of angry people is necessary when there is no legislation process or ability to change an issue through simply voting or a newspaper column. Your article attempts to incorporate reason into the argument about protest, but it is a flawed analysis and does explore the multiple dimensions of protest. |
Ellie Diaz
said:
 |
... Women's prostests in Liberia stopped a civil war, got the president/war criminal exiled, and helped bring in Africa's first female head of state. In this decade. Protest can often be nothing but a show, but when it's used effectively, it can bring immense change. (Check out the film Pray The Devil Back To Hell for more info on Liberian women effecting change through protest). |
silkroad online gold
said:
 |
... Do you know the Sho Online Mun, in here you can get the Sho Mun. I know you will like Sho gold. because it is cheap Sho Online gold. I want you to buy the buy Sho Online gold. It is a very nice game silkroad gold, I like sro gold. You can play it silkroad online gold, you can buy the cheap silk road gold. You smart and buy cheap silkroad gold. |
uppower
said:
 |
... wow power leveling wow powerleveling powerleveling power leveling wow gold powerleveling World of Warcraft power leveling wow power leveling wow powerleveling powerleveling power leveling wow gold powerleveling World of Warcraft power leveling |
wow power leveling
said:
Scott
said:
 |
... I wholeheartedly agree with this article. Being a college student writing for a speech, I chose my (as shown to be here) completely rational dislike for public protest as my topic. As I'd like to add as well, valuable time that is spent protesting could be spent improving families, friends, and lives by doing something constructive. |
rappelz money
said:
 |
... To buy rappelz rupees , it is not the aim of the rappelz. It is the game which brings a lot of happiness to me. We buy the rappelz gold together. The beautiful story, we can not be forgotten, buy rupees . You will not regret to have rappelz money . So I will continue to have cheap rappelz rupees , it is a beautiful fairy tale, it looks like my life. |
angels gold
said:
 |
... Do you want to know the magic of online games, and here you can get more angels gold. |
angels online gold
said:
|
... Maybe you know not too much about game gold, but here you can realize your dream. |
cheap angels online gold
said:
|
... If you have any good advice, please post it on our website, and our after service is also good |
cheap Atlantica online Gold
said:
 |
... or you will lose the choice if you do not have cheap Atlantica online Gold. |
ghost gen
said:
|
... Have you heared about 9Dragons which you need use http://www.ghostonline.us to play, and you can also borrow http://www.ghostonline.us from other players? |
wow gold
said:
 |
... http://www.withwowgold.com/Powerleveling.php wow power leveling http://www.wowgoldliver.com/powerleveling.php wow power leveling |
wow gold
said:
 |
... When the high elves wow gold are striving for survival against the trolls, violent shock army of lordaeron continent students are facing humanity to consolidate their tribal lands, these primitive tribe attacks of other ethnic groups, no care what honor when settlements and racial solidarity. Finally, a named arathi tribal realize troll has become for humans do not neglect the threat. Hope all the arathi tribe by tribe, so they can now organized a united front against the trolls army. Resourceful arathi department 6 years of falling YongJi, MouHe force with their opposites beat all the tribes. Every defeat a tribe, arathi tribes are given by the wow gold people to conquer their peaceful life and equal rights, therefore, they won the defeated loyalty. Finally the arathi tribal contain many various tribes, their troops also rapidly growing up. They can be confident in himself to beat the troll army, even 永恒之塔代练 if necessary can beat the isolation of the elves, arathi warlords in lordaeron to build a strong fortress southern city. This is called the rapids city-states became the arathi people -- capital of arathor. With the prosperity of arathor and mainland have all humans everywhere to safe and reliable rapids. Under the same belief in human solidarity, numerous tribal gradually developed a powerful civilization. King of arathor butyl know north of esomeprazole elves is being troll continuous siege, but he refused to use him as the life of people to help unknown elf risk. wow gold Many months passed, about the elves are prevailing in the gradual spread rumors of lordaeron. When the ambassador to exhaustion quayle salas, solana rapids DingCai realize troll threat is so great. The elves, tell sola troll army very big, when quayle salas, they were troll to destroy the forces will be down. Despair because of the elves in urgent need of military aid to promise that, the human species was selected to exchange their magic resistance troll troops in to help elves. Although all of any cheap wow gold spell esomeprazole distrust of necessity, but he was promised to support the elves. Soon, a group of elf mage rushed to rapids and began to teach a group of human memory of magic. The elves found that although mankind in casting appear to compare clumsy, but they still have a magical an amazing talent. One personal learning some very basic elven magic, these aion代练 people just enough to help against the trolls elves. The elves are convinced that they have for the human apprentice aid in combat ready, then left back, and cheap wow gold the rapids powerful army esomeprazole butyl king fought. |
asdf
said:
 |
... world of warcraft power leveling wow power leveling power leveling wow gold 橡塑发泡 直流电源 paper cup machine Mass air flow 程控交换机 餐饮软件 餐饮软件 收银机 automatic rigid box line paper converting and wrapping machines automatic box makers rigid set-up gift box,paperboard converting equipment 气动马达 气动搅拌机 防爆马达 防爆搅拌机 气动搅拌机 空气马达 防爆马达 气动马达 油漆搅拌机 油漆搅拌器 气动搅拌器 防爆搅拌器 油墨搅拌器 油墨搅拌机 安检门 金属探测器 金属探测仪 thermoforming Equipment bag making machine 工业设计 产品设计 储罐 中药提取设备 乳化机 反应釜 真空干燥箱 厚壁钢管 power leveling wow power leveling paper box paper box equipment thermoforming Equipment Plastic Machinery Plastic Machine 马达 气动马达 搅拌机 |
wow account
said:
 |
... We at accountmmo.com are dedicated in offering you a full range of WoW account and gold selling services. We only sell wow account so you can feel totally safe buying from us as we only sell accounts with full original owner details and history.Simply Choose US or EU account from our many options below and receive your character within 15 minutes!Buy wow account here without any worries. Best service and safest delivery for customers are what we can promise to you. Our knowledge of the online gaming industry, secure network, 24/7 support, and quick transactions have earned us a reputation as the MMORPG account specialists. We will provide our customers lower price than any other retailer that you can compare on the whole game account market. So, buy wow account is your good choice! Believe us, believe yourself! |
uppower
said:
|
... wow power leveling wow powerleveling powerleveling power leveling wow gold powerleveling World of Warcraft power leveling wow power leveling wow powerleveling powerleveling power leveling wow gold powerleveling World of Warcraft power leveling |
silver jewelry
said:
 |
... Jade Jewelry Diy Jewelry Eccdssory Supply Fewelry Jewelry Finding Wholesaler Jewelry| Amber Jewelry| Thai Silver Jewelry| Tibet Silver Jewelry| |
wallace smith
said:
 |
... great post sir.. thanks for sharing. really helped a lot here. -------------------------------------------------- Ugg Boots | Uggs |
sro gold
said:
 |
... Unfortunately, silkroad online gold the popular viewpoint is often an incorrect one. One can view the Billboard pop charts for musical confirmation of MS mesosthis principle. In politics, the principle has shown public opinion to be quite reactionary. Many new, innovative and ultimately beneficial policies were at one point rabidly resisted by masses averse to change. Lineage1 adena The French now serve as Exhibit A of such aversion, but the Americans are far from immune to its effects. One among many examples of reactionary American public opinion was the widespread public opposition to the legalization of interracial marriage, as well as desegregation itself. |
asdasdasdasd
said:
 |
... wow power leveling wow powerleveling powerleveling power leveling wow gold powerleveling World of Warcraft power leveling wow power leveling wow powerleveling powerleveling power leveling wow gold powerleveling World of Warcraft power leveling aion powerleveling aion power leveling aion powerleveling aion power leveling |
asdfdsf
said:
|
... world of warcraft power leveling wow power leveling power leveling wow gold 橡塑发泡 直流电源 paper cup machine Mass air flow 程控交换机 餐饮软件 餐饮软件 收银机 automatic rigid box line paper converting and wrapping machines automatic box makers rigid set-up gift box,paperboard converting equipment 气动马达 气动搅拌机 防爆马达 防爆搅拌机 气动搅拌机 空气马达 防爆马达 气动马达 油漆搅拌机 油漆搅拌器 气动搅拌器 防爆搅拌器 油墨搅拌器 油墨搅拌机 安检门 金属探测器 金属探测仪 thermoforming Equipment bag making machine 工业设计 产品设计 储罐 中药提取设备 乳化机 反应釜 真空干燥箱 厚壁钢管 power leveling wow power leveling paper box paper box equipment thermoforming Equipment Plastic Machinery Plastic Machine 马达 气动马达 搅拌机 |
aion kina
said:
 |
... I know that most players use aion kina to get a shiny cool weapon like other players in game. You need enhance stones with aion online kina. The process of enhancing is simple if you have aion gold. You can buy aion kina after clicking enhance, you will see a star rotating about like roulette. The equipment will be enhanced to the next level if you have more cheap aion kina. latale online gold in the game which movement is much like an arcade game. We know, the latale gold can exchange the real money of the reality. The world you are enjoying in latale money can entertainment and get to know new friends. This economic structure lead buy latale online gold has one kinds of real value in the real world. You can use cheap latale gold to purchase various items of course, there are need to change. |
wow gold
said:
 |
... The Colts rankworld of warcraft goldcheap wow goldwow or 25th in the NFL against the run and, wow power levelingworld of warcraft goldwow powow oron the road, with quarterback issues, buy wow gold |
