| 10 February 2009
I have to make a confession: I am obsessed with the movie The Dark Knight. I think I’ve watched the DVD about forty times - and it only came out two months ago. The film has even leapfrogged Dr. Strangelove, Braveheart, and The Big Lebowski, and is firmly ensconced behind Godfathers I & II on my list of favorite movies. The movie combines a realism that gives it a human quality not seen in many comic book adaptations, yet never lets you forget that it is, after all is said and done, a comic book.
Andrew Klavan, though, writing for the Wall Street Journal about a week after the film’s release in July, believes that the film is an homage to now-former President George W. Bush - even going so far as to claim the “Bat Signal” used by Commissioner Gordon bares a close resemblance to a “W”.
Klavan avers The Dark Knight,
“...is at some level a paean of praise to the fortitude and moral courage that has been shown by George W. Bush in this time of terror and war. Like W, Batman is vilified and despised for confronting terrorists in the only terms they understand.”
This is, of course, absolute nonsense more suited to a child than anyone who can refer to themselves as a “grown up” and keep a straight face. Klavan goes on to compare the movie favorably to other big budget hits like 300 and Lord of the Rings (movies I also love) - while ignoring the fact that 300 champions militarism, eugenics, and a monarchical system - bemoaning the fact that “conservative” views of moral clarity are relegated to the world of fantasy. This, of course, is only possible because the idea that the world is merely split between opposing camps of good and evil is a fantasy unto itself.
Klavan tells us, “And like W, Batman understands that there is no moral equivalence between a free society -- in which people sometimes make the wrong choices -- and a criminal sect bent on destruction.” This, though, blurs the line between fantasy and reality once again. Al Qaeda is not the Joker and George W. Bush (or Barack Obama, George Washington, or any president) is not Batman. Batman can make judgements that eschew moral equivalency because Batman lives in a world that does not exist. Al Qaeda is not a nihilistic organization. Though undoubtedly willing to employ violence, destruction, and murder, Al Qaeda does have a purpose, and one does not have to agree with that purpose to be cognizant of it.
Should the American people put there faith in a hope that President Bush - or Barack Obama - would have the moral fortitude that Bruce Wayne possesses? Are we to expect any person to not allow the type of power a president can wield to corrupt them? This would require Americans to suspend, not only their disbelief, but their system of government that keeps that type of power in check even in the face of evil. No adult should be naive enough to think that a president can be as incorruptible as Batman.
Klavan destroys his own argument in his third paragraph when he suggests that “Like W, Batman sometimes has to push the boundaries of civil rights to deal with an emergency, certain that he will re-establish those boundaries when the emergency is past.” This certainty about reestablishing the civil liberties of the American people is perfectly fine when it has long been argued by former President Bush, former Vice President Dick Cheney, and others in both the former and current administrations, that the threat from terrorism will never end. Therefore, the emergency Klavan describes will never be over - and, more importantly, the civil liberties decimated in the name of stopping evil will never be restored.
That, of course, is the ultimate tragedy hidden in the absurdity that Klavan proposes.
So, to paraphrase Lloyd Benson’s famous admonishment from the 1988 vice presidential debate, “I know the Dark Knight, I have seen the Dark Knight, and Mr. Klavan....George Bush is no Dark Knight.”
TrackBack URI for this entry
Subscribe to this comment's feed
Louis Vuitton bags
said:
 |
... http://www.replica-bags-sale.com/ Louis Vuitton has won itself a world leading brand repute in the fashion industry over the past decades, which is a symbol of delicacy, high quality and comfort. At our louis vuitton online store, all of the Louis Vuitton Purses and Handbags are the best among the Spring and Summer fashion products,such as Louis Vuitton Speedy 25 and Louis Vuitton , which are the newest and most popular styles of Louis Vuitton Handbags that you can't miss. |
New York Rangers
said:
 |
... YS0315H4If thou wouldest live long,live well;for folly and wickedness shorten cheap nhl jerseys life. Each year one vicious habit rooted out,in time minght make the worst man good nhl montreal canadiens throughout.None but the well-bred man knows how to confess a fault,or acknowledge himself in an error.If you do what you should not,you must hear what nfl jerseys cheap you would not.Let thy vices die before thee.Act uprightly,and despise calumny.Dirt may stick to a mud nba jerseys wall,but not polish＇d marble.An honest man will receive neither money nor praise,that is not his due.The honest http://www.nfljerseymlb.com/ man takes pains,and then enjoys pleasure,the knave takes pleasure,and then suffers pains.He that doth what he should not,shall feel what he would not.The goodwill of the governed will be starv＇d,if not fed by the basketball jerseys good deeds of the governors.The brave and the wise can both pity and excuse,when cowards and fools shew no mercy.Calamity and mlb prisperity are the touchstones of integrity.Who judges best of a man,his enemies or himself? |
nike acg
said:
 |
... YS0315H3They got that way from paying your bills, cleaning your clothes and listening to you talk about how cool you are moncler jackets. So before you save the rain forest from the parasites of your parents' generation, try "delousing" the closet in your own jordans sheoes room.Your school may have done away with winners and losers, but life has not. In some schools they have abolished failing grades; they'll give you as many nike air force 1 times as you want to get the right answer. This doesn't bear the slightest resemblance to anything in real designer clothing life.Life is not divided into semesters. You don't get summers off and very few http://www.onestop-onlineshopping.com/ employers are interested in helping you find yourself. Do that on your own discount air jordan shoes time.Television is NOT real life. In real life people actually have to leave the cheap nike shoescoffee shop and go to jobs. The sting of a reproach,is the truth of it.Virtue and happiness are mother and daugher. |
shox oz
said:
 |
... YS0315H1Activity is the only road to knowledge.A free man obtains cheap jordans knowledge from many sources 1 besides books.A great part to the information I have was acquired by looking up something jordans shoes and finding something else on the way. |
Culture & Society
Music & Film
Sports & Games
Tao of PI