The Case For English As America's Official Language

Find Prometheus on Facebook Support Prometheus

The Case For English As America's Official Language

Inglés, Por Favor

An issue not openly discussed, yet subtly lurking beneath perennial American political debates such as immigration, education and voting rights, is whether English should be made the official language of the United States. Becoming the official language would simply mean that English would be the exclusive language recognized by the government in all communications with its people, and vice versa. This organization believes that America would substantially benefit from making English America's official language, for the following reasons.

1. The lack of a national language has inspired backward, inefficient and racist policy in the name of diversity

The current policy toward foreign languages in American elections is for local communities to provide alternate-language ballots whenever a substantial number of its citizens are known to speak an alternate language. This policy, while well-meaning, ends up being foolish (and racist) for two reasons.

First, those ethnic minorities who are not deemed demographically significant by the state, insignificant as their presence is, who need this bleeding-heart foreign language assistance the most. How does this policy help the sole Icelandic immigrant family with negligible English? The current policy excludes them, because they are ironically too much of a minority to be deemed a protected minority.

Second, those large and significant minority groups - the Spanish-speaking population of Southern California, for example - should need this language help the least. How is it that such a large, entrenched ethnic community cannot inform its people what the Spanish equivalents for "vote", "Republican", and "Democrat" are? Are we to believe that the Spanish speaking community in Southern California lacks bilingual members who are capable of educating its unilingual members in elementary English of civic action?

2. Voters need to understand what they're voting for

With English as the national language, American ballots would never be offered in any foreign languages, and for good reason. By what legitimate justification do we allow non-English speaking citizens to cast their ballots for candidates whose positions, platforms, and other important pronouncements are unintelligible to the voting citizen? The American government, despite periodic legislation coercing bilinguality, mainly issues its decrees in English. One who lacks the capacity to understand and interpret the actions of his government should not be granted the ability to issue elective referenda on that which he does not comprehend to begin with.

3. A national language would in no way infringe on free speech

This organization is a passionate defender of free speech, but we see no way in which a national language would inhibit its exercise. A national language does not make it illegal to speak another language - it merely establishes reasonable prerequisites of comprehension for civic participation. This is no different in its justification than the fact that one must be eighteen before he or she can vote.

Moreover, a higher concentration of English speakers in America in no way harms the nation. In fact, commerce and labor hiring would be eased, and societal communication would be enhanced. As all natives would be completely permitted to retain the use of their foreign tongues, there is no substantial harm.

4. Education, and other considerations

A national language will certainly make public education more effective, as American public schools will be statutorily encouraged to aggressively develop English competency among their students. Currently, American public schools are hamstrung between teaching the unofficial, yet clearly necessary English tongue, whilc being "tolerant" of the indigenous linguistic preferences of their students. A national language will make America's public education policies unambiguous: American students must learn English for effective entry into the political, legal, and social world. It benefits everyone.

The above work is the opinion of The Prometheus Institute.
Trackback(0)
Comments (40)add comment

ugg canada said:

0
...
These watches are made by designer Denis Guidone, who says, “I don't like to http://www.cauggboots.com/ , what I really like is to design time .
 
September 24, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

ugg classic cardy tall said:

0
...
How do you start the process of being womens chocolate UGG roxy tall boots happy? The best practice is to make a list of bailey button fancy things that cheer you up and paste it on your bathroom mirror, to remind uggs bailey button uk you each morning of doing the things that bring happiness. The second ugg classic mini thing that you need to do is list all your qualities. Avoid being in the company of people who ugg sundance II constantly talk about negativity, as it will only put you down. Remember to laugh always. A simple ugg sundance 2 smile can bring a lot of joy. You may even try doing activities that make you feel black uggs classic short good.Another most important thing to remember is not to crib over small uggs for sale matters. Instead, you should try to solve them. A person should always be happy with what he or she has. Just tell yourself – there may be many people who are not as fortunate as you are. So, thank life for whatever you have got.Finally, do the things that bring you ugg boots cheap joy and help you appreciate your own qualities and gifts. There is a saying ugg boots that you should abide by, which goes as follows: it is nice to be important, but it’s more important to be nice. So be ugg classic cardy tall nice, and be happy. http://www.uggsbailey.com/Wome...-5803.html LIJ
 
October 06, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

exclusive sneaker said:

0
...
Thanks for such a great post and the review, I am totally impressed!
Keep stuff like this coming. Very cool. Great pictures!
 
October 11, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

bailey button ugg boots said:

0
...
I just come by your blog and wanted to say that I’ve really liked browsing your blog posts.Please, as you gain information, please update this blog with more information. I have found it very useful.
 
January 14, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

martinjolly said:

0
...
Seems like a genuinely nice bloke as well http://www.thomassabollc.com/ as being a brilliant footballer (what a bargain for Spurs). You don't tend to hear too much about footballers being nice intellignt people in the media nowadays.
 
March 02, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

ed hardy shirts said:

0
...
Thank you for sharing this information, which I learned a lot, but also know a lot of knowledge. I hope I'll still see your information next time.do not miss.
 
April 09, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

pandora canada said:

0
...
Reading this I thought it was extremely informative. I enjoy you taking the time to place this blog piece together. I remember when i again find me personally spending way to long both reading as well as commenting. What ever, it had been still worth it
 
April 12, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

nike boots said:

0
...
Men's Big Pony Polo ShirtsHere is the text of Newsweek's 1975 story on the trend toward global
Men's Black Watch PoloReview Article from The New England Journal of Medicine
Men's City PoloThey wrote the articles, refereed submissions, and served on editorial boards
Men's Crest Polo EasyArticles.com is one of the popular fast approval
Men's Custom-Fit Mesh PoloA full article search will be available as soon as the Dispatch
Men's Dip-Dyed PoloBreaking science news and articles on global warming, extrasolar planets
Men's Ralph Lauren Striped PolosInvestigative newspaper site featuring news on Canada
Men's Ralph Lauren Striped PolosIn most online communities, 90% of users are lurkers who
Men's Flag Polowow this article is really great but what i think its removing the
Men's Icon PoloMassachusetts Biotech and Technology News and New England Local Business
Men's Multi-Striped PoloARTICLES ON COOKERY: A Chaucerian Cookery · Regimen Sanitatis S
Men's PoloWe encourage you to share any articles or material you find
Women's Big Pony ShirtsI doubt Google had any idea that Wadhwa's article was coming
Men's Sash Polo/A>Related Articles: The Holocaust and World War II: Timeline
Men's Striped PoloTo go back to the full article list, click the drop-down control
Women's Black WatchIn this case, paragraph one of the preceding Article will be applicable
Women's City PoloThis is a premium article. You must be a Foreign Affairs
Women's Crest PoloThe top-secret world the government created in response to the terrorist
Women's Dip-Dyed PoloTo see an MSNBC interview with Barkan about
Women's DressGoogle Inc. cut its taxes by $3.1 billion in the last three years using
Women's Flag PoloThe article you just read IS the exposure of this book as a work of
Women's Icon PoloSomeone may have written, or started, the article you are inte
Women's Long-SleevedTrue, Article 122 may be invoked by the European Council to
Women's Match PoloNothing in this article shall prejudice the trial and punishment of
Women's PoloWait, is this what New York Times articles are actually like
Women's Sash PoloI wrote a review article called "The Emotional Dog and its Rational Ta
Women's Skinny-Fit PoloResearch Types of Graduate Fellowships and other grad
Women's Sleeveless PoloSALINA, KS—Local man Scott Gentries told reporters Wednesday
 
April 29, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

Chi Hair Straighteners said:

0
...

Thanks for your interesting post.
 
May 07, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

oakley sunglasses said:

0
...
OAKLEY -- Classrooms were emptied in a hurry Monday when the Oakley outlet District reclaimed some of the space it had been leasing to a church.
cheap oakley sunglasses at the oakleyshop.info that Mountain View Christian Center operates, at 5000 Amaryllis St., quickly had to redistribute students among the remaining oakley eyeglasses and the gymnasium after the school district began changing the locks, saying the church had reneged on the terms of its lease.
"A deal is a deal," Versace sunglasses said in response to why the church couldn't keep using the space given that the district doesn't have immediate plans for it.
--ray ban sunglasses
 
May 24, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

Cheap oakleys said:

0
...
I really like your blog. You make it interesting to read and entertainging at the same time. I cant wait to read more from you.
http://www.ocheapoakleys.com haha
 
August 18, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

COACH OUTLET ONLINE said:

0
...
You can pick from sports activities place on to formal put on totes, depending upon what ever occasion you would like them to use. Consequently, specific curiosity you require to, and also you ought to be nuts about Coach Factory. Whether you are looking for any tote to hold it frequently for your business office or Coach Purses Outlet searching for that trendy add-ons to satisfy completely different outfits, Coach handbags sequence have them all together.


Cheap Coach Purses are pretty favorite and pleasurable within the sector for their unique features, just like superb durability, appropriate style and design and excellent versatility. 1 extra cause is the truth that they are seriously inexpensive in comparison with other brands. An good custom bags sequence is Coach Handbags that are readily available in many colours and designs. It could be the truth that girls adore Coach Sling Bags perhaps because of towards the truth that Coach Factory Store understands and delivers existing fashions with substantial style impression and elegance that girls genuinely love.


Operating these Coach Outlet Online around the sector proper now, you should certainly arm your self using the elegance, design and style impression you need to know for people who possess a Coach bag.

 
September 27, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

Canada Goose Parka said:

0
...
Your blog is very well, I hope can share more wonderful blog with you
 
October 26, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

Cheap NHL Jerseys said:

0
...
Long time no see such a good paper,It gives me inspiration and inspiration.To the author to say thank you,
Hope you to create more good work.
 
November 01, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

Jordan Retros said:

0
...
[h4]http://www.airjordansstore.net/[/h4] will disable your mobile data connection when you've exceeded that limit.You can also
out which functions and apps are consuming the most battery life—not
 
November 26, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

wholesale beads said:

0
...
live handmade, buy handmade!
 
December 20, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

mac cosmetics outlet said:

0
...
Many friends like to wholesale mac cosmetics online. High fashion mac makeup wholesale directly from mac outlet. We enjoy these discount mac cosmetics from year to year.
 
February 14, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

cheap oakley sunglasses said:

0
...
Fashion oakley sunglasses cheap online. More and more people like fake oakley sunglasses which is high quality and at wholesale price.
 
February 14, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

coach online store said:

0
...
International brand to emerging coach purses outlet markets as the main theme. European and American brands in an effort to seek development coach handbags outlet in emerging markets, Italy's Prada and United States coach followed by the Hong Kong cheap coach purses Exchange is typical. Despite Japan effects of the earthquake and tsunami, by Mercedes-Benz's name coach purses for sale is Japan fashion week brought a new atmosphere, and equally fast pace of fashion week.

The other hand, international coach factory store brands on the culture occupied the commanding heights for everyone to see. Unprecedented coach outlet stores luxury market coach factory outlet showing strong growth. Many international luxury brands in the top Museum exhibition, through cheap coach active showing its long cultural tradition and to deepen interaction with consumers.

Reporter seen on the COACH's coach outlet online online shop, on the shop mainly sells merchandise to handbags, cover accessories, jackets, watches, coach factory online jewelry and coach factory online store other products. COACH also went out for special offers up to 50 Taobao Taobao shop, coach for sale selling only on Taobao Mall.

Taobao Mall cooperation coach factory outlet and for the, COACH, President and CEO, Jonathan Seliger, the store will help COACH understand the needs coach factory online and preferences of domestic online shopping customer and accumulated experience in coach online store the field of coach factory outlet online e-commerce, for future market opening in prepare long-term COACH online sales channels.
 
February 17, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

boya badana said:

0
...
I wish you continued success and a very nice page



boyacı
boya ustası
dekorasyon

 
February 18, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

dekorasyon said:

0
...

I wish you continued success and a very nice page
 
February 18, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

boya ustası said:

0
...
Your blog is very well, I hope can share more wonderful blog with you
 
February 18, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

Fake oakleys sale said:

0
...

Fake Oakleys Sunglasses now have been recognized as one of the most coveted. we always offer excellent quality and best fake Oakley sunglasses for sale,fake Oakley sunglasses, Buy Fake Oakleys Free Shipping with BEST PRICES up to 70% OFF。 But referring to the original one, the price is very high, some of us can not afford it, so best cheap replica oakleys is a good choice. We have been in fake Fake Oakleys wholesale for 3 years。Fake Oakley Sunglasses not only wear sunglasses to block the harmful rays, while in the windy weather, it can prevent dust entering the eyes, can be said that our eyes sunglasses is the best haven.

 
February 23, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

discount evening bags said:

0
...
The removable strap will change the backpack into a handbag, very comfortable and shiny. A quality backpack should have padded straps that go over the shoulders, across the chest and around the hips. Women's packs are made with narrower straps and shorter torso lengths. And this dual use women bag has this charm and high quality.
If you like this simple backpack bag, don’t miss it.

hobo shoulder bag
 
February 29, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

replica yachtmaster said:

0
...
I like your blog, but can I give you some advice? If you insert some pictures in your posts to illustrate, it will be more attractive!
 
March 09, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

Emergency watch said:

0
...
I am always indifferent with blogs but when I run into seeing your blogs, I think I may change my http://www.3cwatches.com/best-...-cb12.html .
 
March 09, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

cheap ray bans said:

0
...
When fake ray bans have appeared in the people's life, a variety of cheap ray bans make the people look forward to in the future, along with the fake ray ban sunglassess introduced the newest technology lens, fake ray bans start to become the common talking in the public, now you can all kinds of new color and new dicount cheap ray ban sunglasses are on sale.
 
March 14, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

cheap ray bans said:

0
...
When fake ray bans have appeared in the people's life, a variety of cheap ray bans make the people look forward to in the future, along with the fake ray ban sunglassess introduced the newest technology lens, fake ray bans start to become the common talking in the public, now you can all kinds of new color and new dicount cheap ray ban sunglasses are on sale.
 
March 14, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

monster energy hats said:

0
...
Geoff Schwartz, OT/ OG If the Carolina Panthers elected to get versus tendering Schwartz, there is any group gasp with the PFF crew. Sure Ron Rivera wasn"t responsible if Schwartz been able to finish off 2010 by using a PFF score monster energy hats of 12.Three inspite of actively playing not one but two postures, but it really wouldn"t have already been not easy to watch many taping solutions and find out he"s bought additional natural talent when compared with anything at all they can currently created on the proper section with their set.

 
March 15, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

eGo-T said:

0
...
Since 2008,the electronic cigarette
 
April 03, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

cheap oakleys said:

0
...
These information helps me consider some useful things, such as fake oakley sunglasses and cheap oakley on sale now.
 
April 07, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

cheap oakley said:

0
...
Fashion oakley sunglasses sale at wholesale price. Many people like these discount oakley sunglasses on this oakley sunglasses wholesale online outlet.
 
April 07, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

Nike Penny said:

0
...
thank you very much that you show the article to us ,it is usefull to me !
http://www.nikepenny.com/nike-air-foamposite-one-c-15.html]Nike Air Foamposite One
 
June 07, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

lin jingfei said:

0
...
Recently, sunglasses become the essential items for people to travel. Not only can protect your eyes to block the wind, but Oakley sunglasses also play a beautiful role.Selection of a suitable sunglasses has become a topic of concern.Face of each person is different, each case involve. The selection of sunglasses, you are not satisfied with the parts of cheap oakley sunglasses the face which, do not highlight which parts. For example, the relatively wide cheeks, it is necessary to pick a large box of glasses to adjust the balance of the face, so it looks thin.Also pay attention to discount oakley sunglasses much distance between the size of the eyebrows and on the frame to give people the feeling uncoordinated choice of sunglasses, the best way is do not bother, may wish to try some, in addition to their choice, to ask friends views.
 
July 07, 2012
Votes: +0

ray ban sunglasses said:

0
...
When I travel to anywhere with this top quality cheap ray bans, all people feel that it is fashionable to me to wear such a pair of vogue sunglasses.
 
July 18, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

http://www.chaussures4femmes.net said:

0
...
Carter was the first of the shox spokesman at the 2000 Sydney olympic games, Deep wear shox of VC jumped up and crossed the center of a French high-end to complete dunk action This simple statement only begins to describe the sheer magnitude of the changes that were about to occur to the sport of basketball and to the athletic footwear industry once Michael Jordan entered the league
 
September 20, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

http://www.jerseynfl-custom.com said:

0
...
For the first time in Major League Baseball which also call mlb history, teams from the American League and National
 
October 05, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

north face said:

0
...
The best and most cheap 2013 new north face here. northface coupons From France, Germany, the Netherlands, Belgium, Poland and Europe more than 10 countries dairy farmer 26, the European Union headquarters in Brussels held a demonstration to protest the eu milk purchasing price is too low. north face cheap Parade to small conflict. From 26 began early morning, to the Belgian Brussels highway are in the state of traffic congestion. northface coupons Thousands of dairy farmer drive hundreds of tractor to Brussels set, in the hope that through the demonstration means let the leaders of the European Union to listen to their views. According to the organizers of the event disclosure, there are more than 2000 dairy farmer, more than 800 tractor participated in the demonstration. the north face coupons In the afternoon 4 points, European milk farmers protest demonstrations to a head. Protesters climb up the lifting platform, with high pressure nozzle to the European parliament jet about 15000 liters of milk. In addition, the milk agriculture also lit up two reactor ricks, the whole Luxembourg square a piece of smoke. At that time, the European parliament is in a meeting about common agricultural policy reforms. north face coupon.Cold hard cash is just a thing people say, it won't make your fingers colder. Check out the great North Face gloves and mitts sale, because nobody likes cold, wet hands. Nobody. north face cheap
 
November 28, 2012 | url
Votes: +0

Piaget watches said:

0
...
shopper appeal within a establishment, OA as well ERP require exist together harmoniously, match up with each other, identical to the go-to man, only synergies concerned with the two, with the intention to play highest possible practical use. while at the same time, a number of pot minuscule and / or sap doing this very combination might furthermore aggravate its actual competition in OA, ERP area of interest sectors, in depth exacerbating the aspect involved with collaborative OA exchange reshuffle.
 
November 13, 2013 | url
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy